IPS VS IDS: Full Comparison (Which & Why You May Need Both)

IPS VS IDS
Image Credit: Be Structured Technology Group

Not every organization today has the time or in-house personnel to avert cyberattacks. For example, a firm might not have IPS cybersecurity staff who can analyze logs, identify threats, and perform incident response. As a result, network administrators and cybersecurity firms must make use of these tools to safeguard their networks and stop malicious actors from attacking them. In other words, intrusion detection systems (IDS) and intrusion prevention systems (IPS) are examples of tools frequently used for this purpose. For effective results, it’s important to know the significance of IPS, IDs, vs Firewall, which are best for certain types of organizations, and how to maximize their effectiveness. To help you, in this article, we’ll go over the differences between the systems to help you decide which is best for your organization.

IPS vs IDS: Overview 

It’s important to know when to use intrusion protection systems (IPS) versus intrusion detection systems (IDS). But one must also think about how effective a particular IDS or IPS system is. This is because an IDS or IPS could make a false positive or false negative detection, blocking valid traffic or letting serious threats through, respectively. Even though there is often a trade-off between costs and benefits, a business with a more complicated system can usually expect a lower total error rate. Because both IDS and IPS are important in current cybersecurity strategies, many experts think that combining them is the best way to protect a server. Let’s start by defining these words so we’re all on the same page.

IPS vs IDS: Definition

A passive intrusion detection system checks a network for cybersecurity risks. If the IDS thinks there has been an intrusion, it will sound an alarm and call the police. Additionally, there are a few different ways to categorize an IDS system. One is where it fights. IDS can be set up on a single host to watch network behavior, processes, logs, and so on, or at the network level to watch for potential threats. 

On the other hand, intrusion prevention systems (IPS) provide proactive security. Like the IDS, it looks for threats on a watched host or network by using a signature, anomaly, or hybrid detection. Unlike an IDS, an IPS responds to danger. IPSs not only warn of attacks but also stop them.

IDs vs IPs: Examples of Tools

Many commodities can be purchased independently, examples of IDS vs. IPS tools have been viewed as a separate market for a long time. However, security firms are becoming increasingly interested in combining a variety of security products into “platforms” or other comparable services. They will occasionally sell items or services that are designed on an IPS and have extra features added on top of that.

Also, one thing to keep in mind is that these solutions, like most business software, do not have a clear price tag because vendors work with VARs and frequently offer discounts to customers who have been with them for a long period of time. Many also come in multiple types or tiers that can manage varying quantities of labor.

IDS Vs IPS: How to Choose Tools

Thinking about why you need IDS vs IPS tools is the first step in finding the right one. It’s important to think about how a new solution might fit into your overall cybersecurity strategy as well as the features you require and the assets you want to safeguard.

So, Avoid overspending on a feature-rich IPS system if you won’t be using most of its capabilities. The reason is that a solution that is both cost-effective and well-tailored to your needs is more likely to be the result of some upfront effort to define the problem.

Also, you’ll need to decide between an IDS and an IPS as part of that process. Whether you prefer a passive or active defensive solution is the deciding factor between the two approaches we’ve discussed.

Additionally, the issue of cost will, therefore, be of paramount importance to most businesses. A new solution will require employee training, so be sure to factor that expense into your deployment budget.

IDs vs IPs: Examples of the Best Tools

The most well-known examples of IPS vs IDS programs have been broken down for your convenience. We’ve broken down how each instrument functions independently or as a component of a larger system. Since these are still widely used at corporations of varying sizes, cybersecurity firms that are familiar with them have made the list, along with a number of long-standing and beloved open-source applications.

#1. SolarWinds Security Event Manager

IS an intrusion detection software platform and SIEM system that uses NIDS data to find unauthorized traffic. When the computer finds suspicious behavior, it notifies the user. In the Rule section, users can set alert conditions for events or actions. Additionally, risk assessment reports can be used to guide cybersecurity policies after the application scans the network. 

#2. Trend Micro

IPS software identifies and stops cyberattacks instantly. In order to identify and prevent assaults, the program employs techniques such as deep packet inspection, advanced malware analysis, URL reputation, and threat reputation. Trend Micro also links the detection of threats and the application of countermeasures. The Trend Micro system typically does not react to threats. Instead, it serves as a guide for other systems like ADMs and firewalls. In essence, Keeping an eye on all assets simultaneously is a feat no human could accomplish, thereby making this a good alternative for large and medium-sized cybersecurity firms.

#3. Zeek

Zeek’s advanced features make it a robust platform for enhancing network visibility and security monitoring. Detailed analysis procedures are provided, allowing for application-level semantic analysis. Zeek’s domain-specific language enables site-specific monitoring policies, making it a very malleable platform. Zeek can be used on any site, no matter how big or tiny, and in any scripting language. This is because It is effective across locations and is aimed at high-performance networks. In addition, it is highly stateful and offers a comprehensive archive of network activities.

#4. ManageEngine EventLog Analyzer

To simplify audits, IT compliance management, and log management, use ManageEngine EventLog Analyzer. Over seven hundred and fifty tools, including lob import, agent-based log collection, and agentless log collection, are at your disposal to manage, collect, correlate, analyze, and search log data. 

Additionally, it automatically analyzes log files in a human-readable manner and extracts fields to mark out sections for examining files created by unsupported applications. The built-in Syslog server modifies and collects Syslog automatically from your network devices, giving you a full view of all security-related events. Furthermore, you can protect the outermost layers of your network by reviewing audit log information from devices like firewalls, IDS, IPS, switches, and routers.

#5. Google Cloud IDS

Google Cloud IDS offers network threat detection and protection. Malware, spread, and command-and-control threats are found. You’ll be able to see VPC traffic from every angle. Regular updates, a built-in attack library, and attack signatures from the deep analysis engine will help you find the newest threats. Google Cloud IDS instantly scales and helps with deployment and setup.

In summary, By using IDS and IPS systems, security, compliance, and staff effectiveness will all improve. So, Select the best IDS and IPS option from the list above based on the needs of your business.

IPs Cybersecurity

Cybersecurity reduces information risks and vulnerabilities to safeguard computer systems and networks against illegal access, damage, or inaccessibility. Unauthorized access, interception, use, disclosure, and data are dangers in formation. Hence, Every company’s cybersecurity deployment needs IPS Vs IDs. A simple firewall protects a network, but many advanced threats can get past it. IDS and IPs add another layer of defense, making it harder for attackers to compromise a company’s network.

Therefore, enterprises shouldn’t choose one solution over another; both are important, and many vendors offer an intrusion detection and prevention system, or IDPS, that combines the features of both. Because enterprises need detection and response capabilities to recognize when an assault has reached their perimeter and act accordingly. Cybersecurity businesses are detecting bad actors and limiting dwell time by using effective IPs detection and response technologies, minimizing their damage.

In essence, cybersecurity organizations should know their organization’s needs and what data needs monitoring before choosing an IDS/IPS solution. They should also assess their security department to decide if they want an automated solution, an agency response, or a hybrid method.

Benefits of IPs To Cybersecurity Companies

An intrusion prevention system (IPS) is a way to keep an eye on and control a network. It finds and stops attacks on apps and systems that use malicious inputs to take advantage of flaws in their design. Cybersecurity companies can use intellectual property (IPs) in a variety of ways.

  • fewer risks for businesses and more security
  • More information about attacks means better safety
  • Increased productivity lets all traffic be checked for dangers.
  • Fewer resources are needed to handle and fix vulnerabilities.
  • They can find hacks that hurt a company’s information assets. 
  • releases your security team
  • Keep DoS/DDoS threats from happening.
  • Users’ privacy is protected because IPS records fit the list of known malicious activities.
  • Stop attacks on the SSL protocol or attempts to find open ports on particular hosts.
  • Identify and stop OS fingerprinting attempts

IPS vs IDs vs Firewall

For a strong network security plan, it’s important to know the differences between the firewall Vs IDS, Vs IPS. As much as,  IDS vs IPS examples provide deeper inspection and detection of possible security threats by monitoring network activity, while firewalls act as a barrier to stop unauthorized access to a network.

IPS vs IDs vs Firewall: Differences

Today, too many people make the mistake of choosing a few examples IPS vs. IDS vs. firewalls instead of looking at them as complementary technologies. For better understanding, we’ll delve into some of the most common differences between the various approaches, as they can benefit your organization’s overall approach to cybersecurity.

#1. Function

Based on security rules, a firewall monitors and controls traffic. IDSs detect and inform you of potential dangers in real time, whereas IPSs detect and prevent threats.

#2. Placement

A firewall is placed at the network perimeter, an IDS is placed on the internal network, and an IPS can be placed in either location.

#3.Traffic Filtering

A firewall filters traffic based on predefined rules, while an IDS and IPS can analyze traffic behavior and take action accordingly.  ( IPS vs IDs vs Firewall )

#4. Attack Prevention

A firewall can’t stop threats, but an IDS can find them in real time and warn you. Beyond detection, an IPS takes action to stop threats. It can block data, change it, or even tell the system administrator to take the necessary steps.

#5. Performance Impact

Firewalls have a minimal impact on network performance, while IDS and IPS systems can have a significant impact, depending on their complexity.

#6. Deployment

A firewall is relatively easy to deploy and manage, while IDS and IPS systems require more effort and expertise to deploy and maintain. Also, an IPS in a firewall complements its capabilities, providing additional protection against cyber threats.  ( IPS vs IDs vs Firewall).

Why Would You Use an IDS Over an IPS? 

A security operations center (SOC) analyst can evaluate a potential incident and decide if it needs additional action because an IDS just alerts. However, an IPS attempts to stop the intrusion or fix the problem.

What is the Main Advantage of IPS Compared to IDS?

It takes action itself to block the attempted intrusion or otherwise remediate the incident.

What are the 3 Types of Intrusion Detection Systems?

Intrusion detection systems fall into one of three categories: Host intrusion systems (HIDS), Network-Based Intrusion Detection Systems (NIDS), or hybrids of the two.

What are the 3 Types of Firewalls?

The three main types of firewalls (packet-filtering, stateful inspection, and proxy)

Where Do You Put IDS and IPS?

You can place them at the network perimeter, between different segments, or on critical hosts.

References

0 Shares:
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like