When you are running a small business, you are probably thinking about how you are going to pay and keep top personnel in your sector. You want your employees to feel valued and respected at work, but how do you ensure that everyone is compensated fairly? This is where internal equity comes into play.
We will address your questions on what internal equity pay is, why it is important, and how you can start building an employee compensation system that will keep your staff pleased in the long run.
What is Internal Equity?
Internal equity is concerned with ensuring that employees are compensated fairly and equitably for their contributions to the organization, without regard for personal attributes such as gender, color, or age. In other words, it assures that employees get compensated according to their abilities, responsibilities, and experience, regardless of other circumstances.
By generating a sense of justice and increasing retention and motivation, this approach to compensation can benefit both people and businesses.
Why Is Internal Equity Important in Human Resources?
Internal equity is related to many different aspects of human resources. Employees will be dissatisfied if they discover that a coworker in the same profession and with the same skillset is earning more. This could result in lower production, a poor culture, and lower turnover. Some of the advantages of internal equity are listed below.
- Enhanced productivity. An employer who feels fairly treated is more productive than one who feels tricked or undervalued.
- Lower turnover. Employee turnover is reduced by fair pay since employees feel valued.
- Developing talent. Having evidence that your company compensates its employees fairly aids in attracting top talent.
- Equality. It is critical to guarantee that all employees are treated equitably. Fair pay, as part of this, decreases the likelihood of discrimination litigation. Fair pay also combats the gender pay gap (which we will go into later).
- Improved Culture. Fair pay helps to keep the corporate culture positive and collaborative.
What Is the Importance of Internal Equity in Business?
The importance of internal equity to the business can be argued for numerous reasons. HR does not necessarily have the same objectives and goals as the rest of the company. Understanding this can help you gain the support of other leaders in order to carry out these reforms.
- Reduce employee turnover. Did you realize that replacing an employee costs 1.5 to 2 times the employee’s salary? Reducing turnover also lowers hiring costs, saving the organization money.
- Spend less money. Similarly, preventing and eliminating discrimination claims will save a significant amount of money. According to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the average cost of an out-of-court discrimination complaint is $40,000.
- Boost productivity. Executives are just as concerned about productivity as HR is. The more productive an employee is, the greater the advantage to the company.
How To Calculate Internal Equity
Every business should calculate internal equity since it is both fair to employees and useful to the business.
Step #1: Perform an audit
An internal audit is a method of comparing and ensuring that what you are now paying each employee is equivalent. Audits frequently examine the function (including job title and description), the employee’s experience, and all pay (wages, benefits, and bonuses).
Step #2: Look for Inconsistencies
While going through the audit, keep an eye out for any pay disparities between similar positions and make a note of them. A spreadsheet is an excellent tool to keep track of all differences, and it may often be generated directly from data that has already been collected. A spreadsheet is an excellent tool for HR to track the progress of pay equity.
Step #3: Seek an Explanation
When investigating pay disparities, search for rational answers. It is tempting to focus exclusively on job duties and pay, but there are numerous additional elements to consider, such as education level, seniority, and location. If you utilize an HRIS system, you can frequently make remarks on the employee profile. Otherwise, a secure document, such as the spreadsheet indicated above, is preferable.
Step #4: Make Any Required Changes
When discrepancies are discovered and there is no reason for the pay disparity, adjustments are required.
When money is scarce, it can be difficult for some businesses to make changes. HR can take one of two actions. The first option is to keep the employee with the higher pay at that rate until the equivalent employee is paid at the same rate. With this approach, it is critical to pay the first employee with other forms of compensation, such as bonuses, rather than salary increases.
Another wonderful strategy to avoid future injustice is to create or reevaluate compensation ranges. Salary ranges, while not the primary preventative action, can assist close the pay gap in the beginning.
Step #5: Be Open and Honest
Employees value honesty, and this is especially true when it comes to pay. Transparency is essential throughout the process: before, through, and after. Transparency in advance occurs when a corporation is open about its pay ranges and compensation philosophy. It entails being honest about audits and pays disparities that are discovered. Following the audits, transparency means that the company is upfront about the improvements and adjustments that have been made.
Pay Inequity in Common Situations
Listed below are a few examples of prevalent internal imbalances that can be improved by conducting audits and making modifications on a regular basis.
#1. Gender
According to a 2020 estimate, women earn 82.3% of what men earn. To put it another way, women would have to work an extra 42 days per year to earn what men do.
In 2017, 42% of women reported gender discrimination at work, compared to 22% of males. Pay equity was one of the most commonly cited types of discrimination. Employed women reported earning 25% less than men doing the same job, whereas males reported earning just 5% less than women doing the same job.
#2. Race
Many people in the United States are aware of the gender pay gap, but even fewer are aware of the racial pay discrepancy. White guys make 87% of what black men earn. Hispanics make up 91% of what white men make.
The disparity is considerably wider for black women, who are paid only 63% of what white males are. In a low-wage occupation, this equates to a $14,300 annual loss. In a high-wage occupation, the annual loss is closer to $40,000. This demonstrates that the combination of gender and race results in even greater pay disparity.
#3. Education
Even with a college degree, a black or Hispanic worker sometimes earns less than a white worker with the same (or less) education. Education level is an excellent technique for measuring pay disparities since it frequently reveals disparities between genders and races.
Challenges In Implementing Internal Equity
Implementing internal equity might present unique issues for HR departments. Here are some common difficulties you may encounter:
#1. Employees’ resistance to change:
It is natural for employees to fight change, especially when it comes to compensation. To address this issue, clearly describe the benefits of internal equity and involve employees in the process of developing a fair and transparent pay structure. Consider your employee value proposition: how will it benefit them, and how can you communicate this to them?
#2. Budget, staff, and time constraints:
You may experience difficulties assigning the necessary resources to execute internal equity. Organizations might start small and progressively grow from there. For example, before implementing any changes, HR can focus on certain job positions and do a detailed job analysis and performance analysis.
#3. Leadership support for internal equity initiatives:
Implementing internal equity initiatives can be difficult without leadership backing. Human resources departments can educate leaders on the benefits of internal equity and how it can boost employee happiness and retention. You should also make certain that company leaders support the idea of having a fair and transparent pay system.
#4. Managing employee expectations and concerns:
Employees may be concerned about the impact of internal equity on their pay and may anticipate fast adjustments. The approach and timing for establishing internal equity should be properly communicated by your HR team. Allow them to feel heard and respected as well! It is also critical to be as open as possible about any pay gaps and how you plan to address them. According to a recent Talent.com study on pay transparency, 77% of study participants believe that pay transparency fosters a just and inspiring atmosphere.
Internal Equity Best Practices
As an HR professional, you want to make sure that remuneration is reasonable and fair throughout the firm. Here are some crucial steps to achieving internal equity:
#1. Perform a complete job analysis
This entails explicitly outlining the many components of a position, such as the duties, responsibilities, and qualifications required. Consider the requirements for becoming a software developer. You should define the precise programming languages and software tools in which they must be adept, as well as any required schooling or certificates.
#2. Create a job evaluation system
A point system, in which jobs are rated on a scale based on preset criteria, is a typical way. This helps to guarantee that positions with comparable degrees of responsibility and requisite qualifications are appropriately rewarded.
Perform a pay study, which includes evaluating salary data to discover any pay inequalities based on criteria such as gender, ethnicity, or age. This research will offer insight into pay differences, such as whether female employees in the same job category are routinely paid less than male employees.
#3. Create a pay structure:
This entails developing a mechanism for calculating employee pay based on job value and market rates. You may opt to pay employees at or over the market wage for their position, or you may pay a premium for particular talents or experience.
#4. Communication is essential:
How will you inform everyone in the company? Every employee should understand how their pay is calculated and how they might grow within the firm. This can be accomplished through frequent performance assessments, compensation reviews, and innovative modes of internal communication such as Slack or Notion documents.
Companies That Have Used Internal Equity Strategies
Let us look at some examples of successful organizations that have utilized internal equity approaches/policies:
#1. Salesforce
Salesforce has created an internal equity program that includes pay audits on a regular basis to guarantee employees are paid fairly and equitably. Here are some major lessons learned from the program’s implementation:
- There are regular pay audits.
- The pay was made transparent.
- Employees were a part of the process.
#2. Buffer
Buffer has created a clear wage formula that considers aspects like as role, experience, and geography. As a result, they’ve:
- Data was used to inform pay decisions.
- Employees were informed about the pay structure.
- Ensured that everyone is adequately compensated for their contributions
#3. Patagonia
Patagonia’s fair trade certification program assures that all employees get fair and equitable pay. This includes thinking about the ramifications of pay decisions beyond the immediate workforce and building a clear set of values to govern their pay decisions.
Keep in mind that there are numerous techniques that businesses can take, and what works for one corporation may not work for another. When it comes to your own internal equity structure, do not be scared to think outside the box.
How to Keep Internal Equity in Your Company
Implementing internal equity is merely the first step. The real challenge is keeping it continuing over time. It is not sufficient to establish a fair and transparent pay structure once and then leave it alone. To ensure that your strategy is aligned with the organization’s values and goals, you must regularly analyze and adjust it. Here are some ideas for how to keep addressing this inside your organization:
#1. Review the pay structure on a regular basis.
You do not want to wait for pay equity issues to escalate into a major issue. You may identify any disparities and ensure employees are treated properly by performing frequent pay structure evaluations. Assume you discover that your top-performing sales team is not being compensated in the same way as a lower-performing team. Regular evaluations can assist you in identifying incidents like these and correcting them before it is too late.
#2. Based on employment market or organizational demands, update the pay structure.
When it comes to pay, it is also critical to stay current. The labor market can be volatile, and your company’s requirements may shift over time. It is critical to keep up with these changes and adjust your pay structure accordingly. If you observe that salaries for a specific role have risen in the job market, you may want to reconsider adjusting your pay structure to ensure that your employees are being fairly compensated and remain competitive with other organizations.
#3. Address and correct any pay inequalities
Disparities in pay can occur even with the best intentions. To sustain internal equity, it is critical to confront and correct these inequities. For example, you may find that a female employee gets paid less than her male equivalent for an identical work role after doing a review. You can remedy this gap by raising the wage of the female employee to match that of her male counterpart.
#4. Employee communication must be consistent.
Let us face it: no one loves being kept in the dark about their pay. That is why it is critical to maintain regular communication with your staff regarding the pay structure and any adjustments. It not only fosters trust, but it also assists employees in understanding how their pay is calculated. So, keep your employees informed of changes by conveying them via multiple channels such as emails, company All-Hands meetings, or one-on-one meetings.
#5. HR processes should be fair and consistent.
This means that you must guarantee that your organization’s recruiting, promotion, and remuneration policies are fair and consistent. For example, you may have a standard salary range for a specific job role that should be applied uniformly across the organization. Make it clear if your compensation plan varies by geography.
Internal vs. External Equity
Individuals frequently struggle to grasp the concepts of internal and external equity. They must keep in mind that these two concepts are not interchangeable; they have separate properties. To clear up any misconception, one must examine their key differences. So, let us take a look at them.
| Internal Equity | External Equity |
| It looks at fairness within an organization. | External equity considers how the benefits and pay offered by an organization measure up against other businesses in the industry. |
| It ensures the maintenance of fairness throughout a business based on similar skills, knowledge, performance, experience, and responsibilities. | External equity offers a basis for salary adjustments, structures, and competitive job offers. |
How Does Internal Equity Analysis Work?
To assess their company’s internal equity, business owners can take the following steps:
- Plan ahead of time and thoroughly.
- Investigate pay policies.
- Gather as much information as possible.
- Contrast employees’ work in one position with that of others in similar ones.
- Examine the collected data.
- Determine if the disparities in pay are legally justified.
Finally, business owners must take the required steps to mitigate pay disparities (if any exist).
Conclusion
Employees should be paid fairly and equally for their services to the organization, without regard for personal attributes such as gender, color, or age. Conducting an in-depth job and pay study in your firm, constructing a job evaluation system, creating a pay structure, and publicly conveying it to your workers
Employee reluctance to change, inadequate resources, a lack of leadership support, and managing employee expectations and concerns are some of the problems.
Your organization can preserve internal equity by reviewing evaluation and pay on a regular basis, adjusting the pay structure based on changes in the labor market, correcting pay inequities, and communicating consistently with employees.
Related Articles
- INTERNAL FINANCE: Meaning, Types, Importance & Examples
- AUDIT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM: Types and Best Auditing Tools In The Market
- MAX CONTRIBUTION TO 401K: Limits & 2023 Comprehensive Guide
- FAIR CREDIT SCORE: Personal Loans With Fair Credit Score
- PAY EQUITY: Importance of Pay Equity Policy
References
