NONPROFIT INSURANCE: Coverage, Cost & Best Providers

Nonprofit Insurance
Image by Freepik

Nonprofit organizations participate in a variety of high-risk activities. This means choosing the correct insurance policy (or policies) is critical to preventing your company from losing money unexpectedly. However, selecting the best nonprofit insurance from all of the options can be challenging at times. To go about this, look for the best nonprofit insurance organization coverage, quotes, and program to find the best pricing for your plan that suits your demands.

Nonprofit Insurance: Overview

A nonprofit organization is a group organized for purposes other than generating profit and in which no part of the organization’s income will be given to its members, directors, or officers.

There are a lot of insurance companies that offer plans for nonprofits. However, not many of them give them the personalized help that many of them need when they’re choosing coverage. Some groups, like the Nonprofits Insurance Alliance and GuideOne, have a wide range of policies only available to nonprofits and other related groups.

 Some providers, like AmTrust and The Hartford, work with businesses of all kinds and also have agents who know how to meet the needs of nonprofits. In either case, before you make a choice, it’s best to get in touch with the provider and ask about their experience with charities and the type of organization you run.

Nonprofit Insurance Coverage

Even though standard business insurance companies often provide insurance coverage for nonprofits, not all business policies can meet their specific needs. Make sure to find the best nonprofit insurance. To do this, you need to think about the type of group you run, your budget, the needs of your officers, staff, and volunteers, and the level of coverage you need to protect your property and assets. 

We’ve listed some of the most common types of coverage for nonprofits, along with insurance companies that have a history of providing good coverage and working with charities correctly. Among the things we looked at when comparing insurers were premiums, deductibles, the types of businesses they covered, and their financial security ratings from AM Best.

Nonprofit Insurance Coverage: Types

Many nonprofits work on very tight budgets, so one big cost that comes up out of the blue could wipe them out. For this reason, it is smart for businesses and nonprofits to get the right insurance to protect against the biggest (or worst) threats. The types of insurance required by a nonprofit will vary depending on its size, location, and operation, but here are some examples of coverage that nonprofits should consider:

  • Cyber Liability
  • General liability insurance
  • Property Insurance
  • Auto Insurance
  • D&O insurance
  • Compensation for Workers
  • Crime Coverage

Nonprofit Insurance Program

In 2021, the Center for Effective Philanthropy said that 88% of the nonprofits they asked had recently changed the programs they offered. There’s no doubt that a scalable and flexible program development process is important since only 12% of current nonprofit insurance don’t need to make any major changes to their program lineup.

This means that whether your nonprofit insurance is running smoothly and is ready to start a new program or you’re just starting your first service, you need to know everything there is to know about the new program development process so you don’t end up like so many other organizations like yours.

Thus, a nonprofit insurance program is an ongoing, well-planned attempt to help people in some way or provide a service. It’s not the same as an initiative, and it’s part of the organizational structure of the nonprofit, not the nonprofit itself.

Nonprofit Insurance Program: Development Steps

To that effect, we made this guide for program directors and nonprofit founders who want to know what to do when they first start a new insurance program. Here, we’ll help you make a plan for the launch of your newest program by going over each step of the process of developing a charity program and giving you helpful hints along the way.

#1. Do an Assessment of Needs

Finding out if there is a real, measurable need for the work or service your nonprofit does (or wants to do) is called a needs assessment. A needs assessment is the first thing that you must do before you can start planning your programs or even starting a nonprofit. When you do your needs assessment, you should try to answer the following questions:

  • Could you explain what the problem is that you want to solve?
  • Have any groups have tried to solve this issue before?
  • What is the major part of the issue we need to fix? As an example, how 
  • A lot of people might use what we offer, right?
  • Where did what we know about how to solve the problem come from?

#2. Get a Team Together

The next step is to start putting together a team if your needs assessment shows that there is enough reason to start a new program. We will talk about the three main types of charity workers and what they do below, along with ways to get them to join your team.

  • Members of the Board

Putting together a board of nonprofit leaders should be the first thing that every organization does. Board members take on duties related to advancing your organization’s goal, such as hiring more nonprofit professionals, keeping an eye on the creation of new programs, and making sure the organization complies with all applicable laws. Talk to people in your network who have an interest in your cause to find board members. 

  • Staff 

Individuals with jobs like program director, events manager, communications expert, and volunteer coordinator will be on your staff. For the sake of this guide on how to start a new nonprofit program, we recommend that you put the search for a program head at the top of your list. Due to the fact that staff members receive a salary, job boards are the best place to find people to fill these positions.

  • volunteers

To get the word out about their services, run programs, and run fundraising events, many nonprofits rely on unpaid workers. While volunteers give their time for free, it will probably be a constant task for your group to find new supporters. To make it easier for nonprofits to find, hire, and train volunteers, you can use the volunteer management software.

#3. Create a Program Plan

Once you’ve got a team behind you to provide support and bounce ideas off, you should start program planning. A program plan is a document like a business plan that helps with getting grants and making programs better. Writing a program plan takes study and the ability to think strategically, but it is an important step in the development of a program.

#4. Write a Case for Support

At this point in the process, you’ve done a needs assessment, assembled a team, and worked through the process of creating a program plan. Next, you need to get the attention of potential donors with a case for support. A nonprofit organization makes a case for support when they want to ask for money from people. This document’s job is to explain what your group does, how it helps people, and, most importantly, why someone might want to donate to you.

#5. Start Up Your Program

You’ve done your homework and put together a team. Now it’s time to start your program and start working toward your goals. But don’t worry—we’ll leave you with a few last tips to make sure the start of your program goes as smoothly as possible, like;

  • Set a start date
  • Make an implementation plan
  • Invest in resources that will bolster your program’s success.

Best Nonprofit Insurance 

Some of the best nonprofit insurance companies offer specific coverage, like management liability, include volunteers as insureds, give you access to umbrella coverage, and know exactly what the nonprofit industry needs

Best Nonprofit Insurance: What to Look for in Nonprofit Insurance

The following questions might help you narrow down your options and select the best nonprofit insurance provider and coverage for your organization: 

  • Is the provider familiar with nonprofits?
  • What does your current policy, if any, already cover? What gaps are there?
  • Does your current or prospective provider provide policy bundling options?
  • Is the policy tailored to your industry’s specific requirements? 
  • Can the policy be modified to accommodate changes in organizational structure and size?
  • Who and what is covered? For example, does the policy cover all volunteers? Is property protected while in transit? 
  • What do current or previous consumers have to say about their experience (e.g., customer reviews)? 

Best Nonprofit Insurance: Examples

With our own set of criteria, we looked at each company and chose the five best nonprofit insurance companies you can request quotes;

#1. The Hartford

Hartford has been giving charity insurance for a long time. It passed all but one of our tests because it was financially stable enough to handle many claims, it had a lot of coverage options that could be tailored to the needs of nonprofits, associations, and even international charities, and it had a team of people working directly on claims. You can usually get a price online, but if you can’t, you can call and talk to a customer service rep or a local agent.

#2. Thimble Insurance

Thimble Insurance is an insurance company that only covers small businesses, even nonprofits. It got good marks for how convenient it is and how well-thought-out its policies are for short-term events. Nonprofits frequently hold these kinds of events, whether they’re for marketing or to raise money, and many standard policies don’t cover them. But Thimble does offer special event insurance for charities. You can get nonprofit insurance quotes for a special event online or through the app in just a few minutes.

#3. Philadelphia Insurance Companies (Phly)

Philadelphia Insurance Companies (Phly) is a great agency for nonprofit insurance because it offers a lot of different types of insurance. For organizations run by a board, it has developed a management liability package known as Flexi Plus Five. This company is great for nonprofits that report to a board and want an agency that will handle their policy, policy maintenance, and claims. It got high marks in our evaluation for having a strong website.

#4. Nonprofits Insurance Alliance

The Nonprofits Insurance Alliance company has been around for more than 30 years and is the only charity insurance provider. Many people know them for their many non-profit policies, highly satisfied customers, high customer retention rate, and free extras they offer to customers. The business is also known for the good risk management services it gives to nonprofit organizations. They were named the best overall because they have so many good plans.

#5. GuideOne

For non-profits like churches, AdviceOne is the best option for property insurance coverage. Additionally, they provide a range of other insurance services that are specifically designed for churches. They offer special choices for their homeowners’ insurance. Supporting customers pick the one that works best for them.

  • Benefits Individualized insurance plans for nonprofits
  • Property coverage options
  • A phone line that works all the time

Nonprofit Insurance Quotes

The price of an insurance policy can vary a lot based on the company, the terms of the policy, the size of the business, the level of coverage, and other factors. So, finding out if the nonprofit organization in question is getting the most for its money is best done by getting several insurance quotes. The company will probably need to fill out an application before an insurance broker can give them a quote. Once there is enough data, a quote can usually be given within two days of filing the request. It might take longer for bigger groups to get a quote.

Nonprofit Insurance Quotes: How To Get

There are several ways to get quotes for nonprofit insurance: online, by email, over the phone, or in person. Also, the nonprofit insurance brokers will ask you about the group so they can give you a good quote.

What is a nonprofit insurance called?

It is also called errors and omissions insurance (E&O).

What is the difference between a for profit and a not-for-profit insurance company? 

non-profits can issue tax-exempt bonds and accept tax-deductible contributions, while for-profits are able to generate funds.

Do nonprofits have liabilities?

A nonprofit can be held responsible for its own actions and omissions (direct liability).

What types of plans are specific to nonprofit employers?

There are three main types of retirement plan options for non-profits.

  • 401(k) Plan. A 401(k) plan is a retirement plan that can be utilized by nonprofits and for-profit organizations.
  • 403(b) Plan. A 403(b) plan is available to non-governmental non-profit entities. …
  • NQDC Plan.


  1. D AND O INSURANCE: What Is It & Who Needs It?
  2. How to Start an Insurance Company: Easy Step-By-Step
  3. The Monopolistic States for Workers’ Comp Insurance
  4. Top Best Health Insurance for Small Business Owners 2023
  5. Top Best Workers’ Compensation Insurance Companies of 2023
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like