Establishing a retirement plan for your company’s employees is a great way to secure your own and their financial futures and to compete for top talent. However, not every pension is the same. This article will offer you the fundamentals you need to choose between a Simple IRA vs 401K plan for a small business. We also added the differences between Sep IRA vs Simple IRA vs 401K. Let’s dive in now!
Simple Retirement Plans for Small Businesses
Companies with fewer than 100 employees and an annual salary of $5,000 or more are eligible to set up a Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees (SIMPLE) plan. It’s possible to use a Simple IRA vs 401K plan. Compared to other retirement savings alternatives, SIMPLE plans have cheaper start-up and maintenance fees and are simpler to implement, but they lack some of the benefits of a conventional employer-sponsored 401(k).
What Is a Simple 401(K) Plan?
Small companies can provide retirement benefits to employees at a reasonable price by using the SIMPLE 401(k) plan. A qualified plan has certain distribution requirements. However, SIMPLE 401(k) plans are exempt from yearly nondiscrimination testing. Any employee who meets the plan’s payout requirements may take their whole account balance at any time because all contributions are automatically vested (100 percent). There is also less room for growth in a SIMPLE 401(k) plan’s yearly contribution limits compared to those of a standard 401(k) plan.
There are a few rules that must be followed by both employers and employees when it comes to SIMPLE 401(k) plans:
- To qualify, companies can’t have more than 100 workers.
- The annual salary that an employee got from their company must have been at least $5,000.
- For employees to be eligible for the SIMPLE 401(k), their employers must not provide any other type of qualifying retirement plan. Employees who don’t qualify for the primary plan may be offered a secondary plan.
- Either a matching payment of up to 3 percent of employee salary or a non-elective contribution of 2 percent of employee compensation is required of all employers.
What Is a Simple IRA, and How Does It Work?
In a simplified employee and employer contribution individual retirement account (SIMPLE IRA) scheme, both the employee and the employer contribute to the IRA on behalf of the employee. Smaller businesses can still offer a valuable perk to their employees by setting up a SIMPLE IRA plan, despite not being able to handle the complexities of standard retirement plans.
A SIMPLE IRA allows you to:
- Each qualifying employee has a separate account to which the business contributes;
- Workers contribute to the plan by forgoing a portion of their pay;
- Employer and employee contributions are used to finance the plan;
- Every worker is always fully vested.
The plan requires the employer to make a contribution, which the company can do in one of several ways:
- If an eligible employee earns at least $5,000, make a non-elective contribution of no less than 2% of their pay.
- Contribute at least 100% of the first 3% of your salary as a matching amount.
Simple IRA vs 401K for a Small Business?
Simple IRA vs 401K plans make it possible for smaller companies to provide their workers with a retirement savings plan. Both of these plans let workers save money for retirement through payroll deductions and offer “catch-up” contributions to those who are over the age of 50. The following are some notable distinctions:
- Loans may be available under a SIMPLE 401(k) plan, but not under a SIMPLE IRA.
- Companies that offer a SIMPLE IRA cannot offer another retirement plan to their employees, with one exception being those who are covered by a collective bargaining agreement.
- Participants in a SIMPLE IRA must be at least 18, while those in a SIMPLE 401(k) must be at least 21.
Differences Between Simple IRA vs 401K
Comparing a Simple IRA vs 401K, there are benefits and drawbacks. First, 401(k) plans are more difficult for business owners to set up and manage, which drives up their costs. The IRS mandates annual tax reporting and nondiscrimination testing for 401(k) programs.
In order to simplify plan administration and guarantee compliance, 401(k) plans may limit participants’ access to certain investment vehicles. Self-directed 401(k)s are conceivable, but SIMPLE IRAs are more common, and both types of accounts give account holders access to a wide variety of investment opportunities such as stocks, bonds, and mutual funds.
Employees can put away more money for retirement with a 401(k) than they could with a SIMPLE IRA. In 2023 (from $20,500 in 2022), the maximum salary that can be deferred into a 401(k) plan by an employee is $22,500, which is $7,000 more than the maximum that can be contributed to a SIMPLE IRA. When compared to the maximum allowable contributions to a SIMPLE IRA of $19,000 in 2021 and $17,000 in 2022, the maximum for those over the age of 50 is $30,000.
For the employer contribution, there is also more latitude. As long as all employees are offered the same employer contribution terms, companies can choose to contribute anything from 0% to 25% of their workers’ pay. In contrast to a SIMPLE IRA, matching contributions are not required to be equal in size.
More Differences Between Simple IRA vs 401K
In a 401(k), employers can set up vesting periods for their contributions. That’s because the matching contribution only kicks in if the worker keeps their job. As a result, staff retention may be improved. Employer contributions to a SIMPLE IRA are immediately vested.
Employees may be able to borrow money against their 401(k) savings. This feature can make retirement plans more enticing to workers by allowing them to temporarily withdraw money for a large purchase or unexpected costs.
Simple IRA vs 401K: Costs and Administration
Get to know more about the difference between a simple IRA vs 401K by checking the costs and administration aspects:
Costs
Your contribution options and flexibility are greater with a 401(k) plan than with a SIMPLE IRA. As a result, they must adhere to more stringent regulations, which in turn necessitate more resources to enforce.
Providers typically charge a setup fee of between $500 and $2,000 for establishing a 401(k) plan due to the administrative burden this can cause for the business. There is the possibility that they will charge an annual fee of $15 to $60 per participant.
The cost to establish a SIMPLE IRA is typically much lower. Many banks and credit unions provide free account openings. The average annual maintenance price per member is between $10 and $25.
A tax credit is available to businesses in either situation to help them deal with the expense. Eligible companies can receive a tax credit of up to $5,000 per year for up to three years under the Retirement Plans Startup Costs Tax Credit to help defray the initial costs of setting up a Sep IRA vs Simple IRA vs 401K plan and educating employees.
If you meet these criteria, you may qualify for the credit:
- You have 100 workers or fewer who received at least $5,000 in pay the previous year.
- One or more people in the scheme are not highly compensated workers.
- You have not sponsored another retirement plan within the past three years.
Form 8881 must be submitted along with your federal income tax return in order to claim the credit.
Administrator Requirements
Companies that offer 401(k) plans must do the following:
- New employees should be notified and enrolled as soon as possible.
- Payroll deductions should be made on the first of the month.
- Ensure the plan doesn’t unfairly benefit highly paid employees by doing “nondiscrimination testing” on a yearly basis.
- Annually submit IRS Form 5500.
- If the plan has more than 100 participants, it should be audited annually by a certified public accountant.
- Allow withdrawals and loans under extreme circumstances
- When required, complete and distribute Form 1099-R to contributors.
Several of these responsibilities are typically contracted out to a third-party administrator by plan sponsors. Offering a traditional IRA to employees can be difficult and expensive for small organizations with fewer than 100 workers. A 401(k) plan can replace a SIMPLE IRA when a company expands or when the employer decides to provide better retirement benefits.
The Differences between a Simple IRA vs 401K for a Small Business
The size of the company and the preferences of the employees are two of the most essential considerations when deciding between a Simple IRA vs 401K plan. Companies can make more informed judgments about their benefits programs if their employees have a firm grasp of the key differences between Simple IRA vs 401K.
- Any company can set up a 401(k) plan for their employees, but only businesses with 100 or fewer workers can set up a SIMPLE IRA.
- With a SIMPLE IRA, you can only put away a smaller amount each year than with a 401(k) plan.
- Employer contributions are necessary for SIMPLE IRAs. 401(k) programs do not require employer contributions, though many companies voluntarily provide them.
- Employees with SIMPLE IRAs are always fully vested, whereas employer contributions to 401(k) plans may be subject to varied vesting requirements.
Which Is Better for You: Simple IRA vs 401K
The capacity to attract and keep talented workers is a major benefit of employer-sponsored retirement plans. Therefore, as a business owner, you should always prioritize your employees’ best interests alongside your own.
Companies that pay more than average tend to attract employees who can afford to put more money into their 401(k)s. Workers who earn a higher income are more likely to wish to increase their retirement savings. A 401(k)’s matching contribution is more malleable, allowing you to put away more money, compared to a SIMPLE IRA’s mandatory employer contributions. (A good 401(k) company match is still a major factor for many workers when deciding between job offers.)
Simple IRA vs 401K for a Small Business
A SIMPLE IRA will be sufficient for your workers if you pay them a smaller salary. Especially for middle-income workers, the $15,500 contribution cap is still rather generous in comparison to other retirement savings alternatives available to them. Keep in mind that employees can still contribute to their individual IRAs in addition to their workplace Simple IRA vs 401K, but that their ability to deduct those contributions may be limited if their income is too high.
The primary advantage of a SIMPLE IRA is the reduced initial and ongoing costs associated with setting one up. A SIMPLE IRA is preferable to a 401(k) if it can suit the needs of your employees. A 401(k) may be more expensive, but it’s well worth it if you need a lot of leeway in making contributions.
Sep IRA vs Simple IRA vs 401K
The following are the differences between Sep IRA vs Simple IRA vs 401K:
#1. Biggest Appeal
Solo 401(k): Because sole proprietors can make contributions in both their employee and employer capacities, they have a fantastic opportunity to maximize tax benefits associated with their investments and earnings.
SEP IRA: Any business owner, no matter how little, can offer a retirement plan to all of their workers (including themselves).
SIMPLE IRA: When it comes to retirement benefits, small business owners with less than 100 employees have more flexibility and cost savings options.
#2. Who Funds Them (And How)
Solo 401(k): You, yourself, and you make a pre-tax contribution from your earnings and an additional post-tax contribution from your own income.
SEP IRA: Payroll contributions to a SEP IRA can only be made by the employer.
SIMPLE IRA: Both the company and its workers, through payroll deductions from both parties.
#3. How Workers Can Qualify
Solo 401(k): Employees should not use this account; it is intended solely for sole proprietors and their spouses.
SEP IRA: If you’re 21 or older, make at least $650 in the upcoming tax year (2021), and have worked for the same company for at least three of the prior five years, you may be eligible for this benefit.
SIMPLE IRA: Employees of any age are eligible to apply, provided they have earned at least $5,000 in each of the two most recent years (they need not be consecutive) and anticipate earning at least $5,000 in the current year.
What Are the Disadvantages of a Simple IRA?
- Employee limitations. SIMPLE IRAs can only be implemented in companies with 100 or fewer employees.
- Total annual contribution limits.
- Lower contribution limits than a 401(k).
- Mandatory employer contributions.
- No loans or Roth contributions.
Who Is Eligible for a Simple IRA?
Employees are eligible to participate in the SIMPLE IRA plan for the calendar year if they have received at least $5,000 in compensation from you in either of the two prior calendar years (which need not be consecutive) and if they are reasonably expected to receive at least $5,000 in compensation during the calendar year.
Can I Open a Simple IRA for Myself?
Both sole proprietors and those in charge of companies with 100 or fewer workers can benefit from the Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees (SIMPLE) Individual Retirement Account.
Can I Take Money Out of My Simple IRA?
Any money you take out of your SIMPLE IRA will be subject to income tax. A 10% or 25% additional tax may be due on the amount withdrawn unless you are over 59 1/2 or meet another exception.
What Happens to My Simple IRA if I Quit My Job?
When you leave a company that participates in the Simple IRA plan, you must wait two years before withdrawing your funds. That means you typically have to wait two years after making the deposit before you can move the money. When you’ve had your Simple IRA for at least two years, you can do more with the funds.
Final Thoughts
Employees who want to maximize their retirement savings and employers that want to recruit top personnel should consider a 401(k) plan due to its high contribution limits and flexible design options. A Simple IRA vs 401K may be the best choice if you’re searching for a simple and inexpensive retirement plan. You should do your homework before committing to any plan and pay special attention to the administrative fees and investment prices. After that, you and your workers will be able to start enjoying the tax benefits of retirement savings.
Related Articles
- 401k ROLLOVER: Guide to Do It, IRA, and Consequences
- SELF EMPLOYED 401K: Definition, Limit & How to Get It
- ANNUITY VS 401k: Comparing the Risk and Benefits
- WHAT IS 401K: How It Works, Benefits & Withdrawal
- WHAT IS CALSAVERS: Definition and How It Works
- 401k INVESTMENTS: Meaning, How to Invest, Companies & Best Investments
References
