What is management by exception
Image source: Business.com

As a manager, you must be able to divide your attention between multiple tasks, each of which appears to be the most critical problem to address. This can be quite burdensome. Thankfully, there are some strategies you can implement to make your work less stressful. Management by exception is one such strategy. And in this guide, we’ll explain the principles on which management by exception works, taking active and passive management as a case study. 

What is Management by Exception?

Management by exception is the technique of analyzing a company’s financial and operational outcomes and only bringing issues to management’s attention if the results differ significantly from the budgeted or expected amount. For example, the firm controller may be compelled to warn management if spending exceeds $10,000 or are 20% higher than projected.

The goal of the management by exception approach is to only task management with the most significant deviations from the business’s anticipated direction or performance. Managers will undoubtedly devote more time to addressing and rectifying these greater deviations. The notion can be fine-tuned so that minor deviations are brought to the notice of lower-level managers, while major deviations are reported directly to high management.

What Does The Process of Management By Exception Look Like?

The overall notion is actually quite simple to grasp, however, it’s not the easiest to put into practice properly. Setting the objectives or norms, assessing the performance of the chosen objectives, examining probable deviations, and resolving exceptions are the only objectives required for the process. Let’s have a look at each section separately:

#1. Establishing goals or standards

The procedure selection process begins with setting the norms. Assume you own a hamburger restaurant and want to keep track of things like sales, expenses, and so on. You would need to define a standard or goal for each task and operation. The standard should be easily quantifiable and attainable. It may be the total number of burgers sold each month, for example. This is the amount you must sell in order to cover your expenses and continue to develop at a sustainable rate. As a result, you would establish the norm, which in this case may be 15,000 burgers sold.

#2. Evaluating performance and comparing it to the norm

Once the norms have been established, you may begin employing management by exception. The most important aspect of the procedure is monitoring the necessary data sets and determining whether or not the actual performance meets the norms. You must verify that you are collecting all important data and monitoring systems in real-time.

The monitoring method can vary depending on the size of your company and the type of data you are monitoring. You can utilize automatic monitoring tools to gather and compress data for you, allowing you to see the results. On the other side, you might manually review the reports to identify any deviations.

As you begin to collect data on current performance, you may begin comparing it to your set norms. You want to do this so that you can spot any deviations from the usual and then deal with them.

#3. Examining the deviation

When comparing your performance data to the norms, there are two possible outcomes:

  • If there is no major variation, you do not take any action. As previously stated, you are not required to respond to minor modifications.
  • If you discover a major variance, proceed to the next step of telling the appropriate management level about the problem. This could be your immediate supervisor or higher-level management. Depending on the method, as a manager, you must either respond to the deviation or report it higher up the chain.

Deviations should not be accepted as they are, and corrective action should be performed only after you have determined the causes for the exceptions. You must keep two things in mind. For starters, a human error or another abnormality could have caused the situation. This could imply that the departure is not as severe as it appears. The second thing to remember is that deviations do not always need to be fixed. In some cases, the variation may be caused by advancements in a specific method. As a result, never begin fixing a problem without first determining the core causes of the deviation.

#4. Taking care of the exception

It is then up to responsible management to deal with the deviation and respond properly. Before you can solve the anomalies, you must first understand the root reasons. Remember that in some cases, your norms may need to be adjusted. For example, if you add a new product to your line, your expenses must rise, and so on. So, rather than simply implementing your management by exception formulas, examine them on a regular basis.

Principles Of Management By Exception

Management by exception is mainly concerned with ensuring that management focuses on policy initiatives and decisions, becoming involved in day-to-day activities only when significant deviations arise. What about the fundamentals? What are some of the key principles that must be present for management by exception to work?

#1. A methodical approach

Management by exception necessitates a methodical approach to work. In practice, this means that all of the organization’s operational demands and requirements must be thoroughly understood and outlined. Essentially, the company must be aware of everything that is going on and must adhere to a clear set of rules. Management by exceptions is impossible to achieve without a well-defined set of standards and processes. Simply said, you can’t detect deviations if you don’t know what the normal or so-called norm looks like.

#2. A thorough organizational policy

The notion of organizational policy is central to the systematic approach. The organization must have a pre-determined and pre-established policy that defines the objectives and policies that management and other levels of the business must adhere to. Having a detailed policy in place will not only make it easier to identify deviations, but it will also ensure that all levels of the business follow the same set of standards.

#3. A strong grasp of exceptions

In relation to the preceding premise, management by exception necessitates that the entire organization is aware of the deviations. You can’t execute the system if the exceptions are kept hidden or only known to the reporting team. The more the team understands what is expected of them and what should raise red flags, the easier it is to recognize problems or prevent them from occurring in the first place.

#4. Appropriate distribution of authority

A principle of proper delegation of authority must be created for the process and structure to work. As previously stated, deviations can be broadly classified into ordinary and unusual behaviors. For authority, there must be a clear understanding of this divide and a well-established command structure. When a problem or an exception occurs, employees and managers must understand what they are expected to do.

#5. Subordinates’ constant development

Finally, as with many management theories and styles, subordinate development must be incorporated into your management by exception framework. I’ll get into the merits and drawbacks of the approach later, but you should know that the system is not easy for staff.

Because management only engages subordinates proactively in the event of a problem, you must ensure that the staff is as skilled as possible. You should provide training not only on the style but also on other aspects of the subordinate’s role. Furthermore, the training should concentrate on enhancing the individual’s managerial qualities. This will provide your organization with smoother succession alternatives and ensure that the next managers originate from within the organization.

What Are The Benefits of Management by Exception?

  • It decreases the number of financial and operational results that management must review, making better use of their time.
  • A minimally invasive reporting option is to configure the report writer linked to the accounting system to automatically print reports at certain intervals that contain the predetermined exception levels.
  • This concept empowers employees to take their own approaches to obtain the company’s budgeted outcomes. Management will only intervene if there are exceptional circumstances.
  • As part of their annual audit operations, the company’s auditors will inquire about big deviations, therefore management should analyze these issues in advance of the audit.

Active Management By Exception

Active management by exception entails leaders controlling and monitoring both activities and outcomes. Leading by exception is intervening at the first sign of a problem to fix and rectify the situation while reprimanding the team member who caused it.

Before we go any further, Let’s understand what transactional leadership is, It’ll help us understand the concept of active and passive management by exception better

Transactional Leadership 

Transactional leadership is the more directive and less engaging sibling of transformational leadership, but it is marginally superior to laissez-faire leadership, all of which are part of the Full Range Leadership Model.

This type of leadership is based on a defined reward and punishment structure for different levels of achievement. It is distinguished from transformational leadership by its emphasis on outcomes, efficiency, and performance rather than people and connections.

Transactional leadership has three distinct components or techniques: active management by exception, passive management by exception, and contingent reward. 

Active Management By Exception In Transactional Leadership

The manager or leader is involved throughout the work in active management by exception, controlling, supervising, and verifying the work of the team members. Because of this intimate participation, the leader can occasionally notice problems before it is too late, and corrective steps can be implemented, even if the repercussions are avoided entirely. This is unlike the passive management by exception.

Active management by exception manager not only prevents problems but is also constantly present, guiding and demonstrating to employees what to do. This allows team members to learn more about error avoidance and receive more direct coaching from their leader. Similar to pacesetting leadership, the leader can set a good example for others to follow.

However, active management by exception, like passive management by exception, is likewise focused on negatives and preventing errors; it is simply more proactive than reactive.

Active management by exception, like most transactional leadership approaches, works well in repetitive contexts where a small number of actions and tasks are completed and the product speaks for itself.

The key to effective active management by exception leadership is to be near enough to the real job to notice faults early, while also ensuring that staff learns from these instances, lowering the chance of future exceptions.

Situations in Which Active Management by Exception Can be Effective

Active management by exception can be effective in the following scenarios:

  • Fast food restaurants 
  • Cleaning services 
  • Logistics and warehousing
  • Assembly
  • Agriculture and low and medium-complexity production environments require manual labor.

Active management by exception leadership, like passive management by exception, has real constraints. The concentration on exceptions limits your objectives, and there is little to no emphasis on the larger picture, such as vision, engagement, motivation, and so on. It does give some continual development, which is vital, but it is more concerned with avoiding difficulties than with overall improvement.

Does Active Management By Exception Work?

Active management by exception works better than passive management, but not as well as contingent reward or transformative leadership. Even in repetitive environments where people simply put in their hours for their wages, a visionary leader can always find an overarching purpose to build commitment, thus boosting performance and reducing employee turnover.

Leaders with aspirations for improvement, as well as the ambition and purpose of improving the people around them, should not settle for this more basic form of leadership, even if it includes participation in the work.

What Is MBO, Its Advantages, and Disadvantages?

Management by objectives (MBO) is a procedure in which a manager and an employee agree on particular performance objectives and then devise a strategy to achieve them. The advantages include:

  • Because management by objectives (MBO) is a goal-oriented strategy that focuses on defining and controlling goals, it encourages managers to plan in depth.
  • There is no job ambiguity or confusion because both the management and the subordinates understand what is expected of them.
  • Managers must define measurable targets, performance standards, and priorities for these targets. Furthermore, the personnel’s tasks and authority are clearly defined.
  • It raises individuals’ awareness of the company’s objectives. 
  • It frequently indicates areas where employees require additional training, resulting in career advancement.
  • The method of periodic evaluation informs subordinates of their performance. Because MBO places a heavy emphasis on definable goals, assessment and evaluation can be more objective, specific, and equitable.
  • It enhances communication between management and employees.

The disadvantages include:

  • MBO can only be successful if top management fully supports it.
  • Subordinates may oppose management by objectives (MBO).
  • There is a lot of paperwork involved, and it consumes too much of the manager’s time.
  • The emphasis is on short-term objectives.
  • Most managers may lack appropriate skills in interpersonal interactions such as coaching and counseling, which are frequently required.
  • The MBO system’s interface with other systems, such as forecasting and budgeting, is quite inadequate. This complicates the overall operation of all systems.
  • Achieving group goals is more challenging.

What Is The Difference Between Management By Exception And Management By Objectives?

The primary distinction between Management by Objective (MBO) and Management by Exception (MBE) is that MBO is a process in which specific goals for the organization are set collaboratively, whereas MBE is a policy in which management devotes its time to investigating only those situations in which the actual result differs.

What is the main aim of management by exception?

Management by exception is an approach to leadership that encourages people to take the initiative and take charge of their own work and initiatives. It entails zeroing in on and examining outliers that matter statistically.

Why is management by exception an effective strategy?

Management by exception makes better use of management’s time by reducing the number of financial and operational results that need to be reviewed.

In Conclusion,

Management by exception is an excellent management technique for ensuring that the manager’s full attention is focused on the most pressing issues. It can help to focus attention and create an environment in which real problems take precedence. Indeed, management by exception can be a useful technique for prioritizing tasks, from organizing daily activities to establishing suitable power structures. It can help ensure that the company meets the highest standards.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is management by exception good?

Management by exception is a great notion for any firm. Managers utilize it to concentrate on company performance rather than the entire business unit.

Who developed MBE?

Around 1968, two American physicists, Chinese-born Alfred Y. Cho and John R. Arthur, Jr., developed the basic MBE technology at Bell Laboratories.

What is passive management by exception?

Passive management by exception means postponing action until mistakes or problems cannot be overlooked any longer.

  1. Management Buyout: Guide To The Management Buyout Process & Financing
  2. How to benefit from business mentorship
  3. 4 bad habits of entrepreneurs that killed Nokia and Blackberry and what you should learn from it.
  4. Executive Summary: How To Write An Executive Summary For Business Plan & Bank Loans


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like