Understanding the various interview structures you might run into is crucial when preparing for a job interview. All Unstructured interviews are an example of a type of interview that does not have a set structure and instead alters according to the conversation’s flow. Unstructured interviews are a type of data collection that relies on participants being questioned to gather information on a subject. Unstructured interviews, also referred to as non-directive interviewing, have no established format and questions are not prearranged.
Here, we compare structured and unstructured interviews and offer advice on how to succeed in them, along with sample questions and responses.
Unstructured Interview
An interview that is not predetermined in its structure but rather evolves as the conversation progresses is referred to as unstructured. This type of interview have variable questions but focus only on the time allotment and people involved, in contrast to standard, structured interviews, which ask the candidate a list of predetermined questions. Unstructured interviews, also known as non-directive interviews,
The most informal interview settings, those for technical or creative positions, and those where the applicant’s personality is a top consideration use unstructured interview formats. Candidates frequently claim that informal interviews feel more conversational than formal. This means that during an informal interview, you might feel much more at ease and confident in telling the truth. Unstructured interviews are typically adaptable, informal, and qualitative. They sound natural and flow like a normal conversation.
An unstructured interview might not stick to a predetermined set of questions, even though the interviewer usually has a few general topics they want to cover. The majority of questions asked in an unstructured interview are open-ended, which means there is no right or wrong answer.
Structured vs. Unstructured interview
An unstructured interview allows you to take the initiative and highlight your most salient abilities and experiences as opposed to adhering to a pre-written script that the interviewer controls, which is the main difference between an unstructured interview and a structured interview. By doing so, you can show the interviewer which of your experiences, abilities, and qualifications make you the most qualified candidate.
Advantages of Unstructured Interviews
Comparing unstructured interviews to other interview formats, some benefits can be found.
#1. It Is Very Flexible and Respondents Are More Relaxed
This type of interview is extremely adaptable and arranged much like regular conversations. As a result, there is more room for discussion and the free exchange of ideas. Unstructured interviews also allow for a more natural flow, which can put your subject at ease. Improved rapport can mitigate the power disparity that exists between the interviewer and the interviewee during the interview.
#2. Reduced Risk of Bias
In a similar vein, respondents with greater influence might be less inclined to skew their opinions in favor of what they believe to be socially acceptable. Because of this, unstructured interviews are frequently a preferred method for research into delicate or upsetting subjects.
#3. More Information and Nuance
They offer more depth and nuance despite employing techniques that are comparable to those of other kinds of interviews, questionnaires, and surveys. There is no restriction on the number of follow-up inquiries you may make, and there is a good chance that they will spark new insights.
Disadvantages of Unstructured Interviews
In comparison to other methods of data collection, unstructured interviews also have a few drawbacks.
#1. Insufficient Reliability and Generalizability
Its flexibility can promote the development of fresh ideas, but it can also reduce their validity and generalizability. The analysis stage can be challenging if participants are not given the same questions, making it challenging to compare their answers. Unstructured interviews frequently have very small sample sizes because of their length, which can result in several biases in the selection and sampling processes.
#2. Extremely Laborious
Both conducting the interview and conducting the analysis of the data from unstructured interviews can take a lot of time. While encouraging long, in-depth responses can enrich the data, it also increases the amount of time for transcription and analysis and increases the possibility of missing crucial information in the mix.
#3. Risk of Low Internal Validity
Furthermore, it can be difficult to keep unstructured interviews “on track” because you run the risk of losing focus due to tangents and side questions. As a result, your study’s internal validity may suffer.
Unstructured Interview Example
#1. Tell Me About Yourself
In an unstructured interview, it is very typical for the interviewer to start by asking, “Tell me about yourself.” This question is ideal for an informal interview because it enables you to direct the conversation toward the points you want to emphasize right away. You can respond to this question by emphasizing your qualifications for the job, outlining your experience to date, and describing your reasons for your interest in the company or field in question.
#2. Describe Your Ideal Job
The purpose of this question is for interviewers to learn more about your professional values and how they may or may not match the company culture. When responding to this question, be sure to highlight both your personal best traits and your ideal workplace. Be sure to adjust your response to the position you are interviewing for.
#3. Which Success Are You Most Proud Of, and Why?
To gauge your work ethic, core beliefs, and level of self-assurance—which can be demonstrated with specific examples of your previous work—interviewers may ask you about your greatest accomplishment. When responding to this question, choose a success that is relevant to the job for which you are applying.
Tips on How to Succeed in an Unstructured Interview
#1. Be Truthful and Authentic in How You Conduct Yourself.
Being truthful when responding to inquiries is crucial because it will make the conversation flow more easily and give you the chance to steer it in the direction you want to emphasize.
#2. Focus On Your Strengths
Discuss your strengths more frequently, and only bring up your weaknesses if the topic naturally arises. If the topic of conversation does turn to something that is not your area of expertise, you can take advantage of the situation to emphasize the value of ongoing improvement.
#3. Address the Specific Questions the Interviewer Is Asking About
Regardless of whether the interviewer has no specific questions prepared or only a few key questions, they will most likely be looking for you to address certain topics in your answers. Make sure you are outlining how you meet the precise skills and qualifications they are seeking by using the job description, the details you gathered from your research about the business and the position, along with any information you learn from the conversation.
Unstructured Interview Questions
The following are some examples of an unstructured interview questions:
- Share with us a mistake you regret making. How might you approach it differently today?
- Which leadership stance do you favor, and why?
- How big was your last project’s team? What part did you play?
- How would you handle a boss whose opinions differ from your own?
- Do you intend to serve in a leadership capacity in the future?
- Can you collaborate with those who are very different from you?
- Name a scenario that you found to be particularly stressful. How did you handle the pressure?
Structured vs Unstructured Interview
An organized interview follows a set format. It consists of a series of sequential, closed-ended questions with the same set of possible answers for each interviewee. The option to choose an answer can be multiple choice, sliding scale, or yes/no. It is occasionally referred to as a “standardized interview” because it uses the same variables to collect data from everyone and asks the same questions of them all.
Unstructured interviews operate in complete contrast to structured interviews, which rely on predetermined questions. Using their intuition, the interviewer may pose questions about the study’s topic. It is typically more informal, more conversational, and laid-back.
Despite not having any prepared questions, the interviewer must make sure they are relevant and cover the topic. Interviewees are frequently unprepared for unstructured interviews because the questions call for thoughtful responses that frequently involve opinions. More casual and open-ended questions are asked during unstructured interviews.
Differences Between Structured and Unstructured Interviews
A structured interview yields a lot of quantitative and impartial information. An unstructured interview produces data that is qualitative and unique. The quantity of data samples, or respondents, can differ significantly between structured and unstructured interviews. A smaller number of data samples were typically used in unstructured interviews, whereas a larger number could be examined in structured interviews.
The same questions are presented to all interviewees during structured interviews, along with the same guidelines for responses. Respondents can be more descriptive during unstructured interviews. Data obtained through a structured interview can be more easily compared because standardized questions and answers are used. Analyzing information obtained from unstructured interviews takes more time.
What Is a Structured Interview and an Unstructured Interview?
In a structured interview, the interviewer asks the participants a set of standard, pre-approved questions in a pre-planned order. For instance, the respondents might be given the option of selecting Yes or No. Contrarily, an unstructured interview is one in which there is not a set of predetermined questions, though the interviewers typically have a list of topics they want to cover in advance. Unstructured interviews have a conversational flow and are typically more casual and open-ended. Open-ended inquiries let respondents express themselves freely in their responses.
What Is One Difference Between a Structured and Unstructured Interview?
An interview that is structured adheres to a predetermined format, and the interviewer stays on topic. An unstructured interview, on the other hand, does not follow any rules.
What Are the Three Differences Between a Structured and Unstructured Interview?
Data is gathered quantitatively during a structured interview, making the information more objective and the process more formal. whereas information obtained through an unstructured interview is qualitative, making the information obtained subjective and the process informal.
Structured interviews involve asking each applicant a predetermined set of questions that have been prepared in advance. Unstructured interviews, in contrast to structured interviews, may not always have a predetermined list of questions. With a clear understanding of the kind of applicant they want for the position, the interviewer asks open-ended questions.
What Are the 3 Types of Interviews?
- Structured interviews: The topics and timing of the questions are predetermined.
- Semi-structured interviews have some questions that are predetermined but not all of them.
- Focus group interviews: Rather than asking one person the questions, a group is presented with them.
What Are the Four Types of Interviews?
- Unstructured (Non-directive) Interview
- Structured (Directive) Interview
- Semi-structured
- Focus group
Conclusion
Depending on the information you want to gather, how you plan to analyze it, and whether you plan to conduct further research, you will use a particular interviewing technique. Structured interviews may be the best option for you if gathering quantitative data is your main objective. Unstructured interviews could be the most effective format if you need more information, want to follow up on previous research, or want to collect qualitative data. An unstructured interview gives the interviewee a chance to show off their personality and soft skills while also giving the interviewer a chance to ask questions and get to know the candidate better.
Related Articles
- VIDEO INTERVIEW TIPS: What Are the Tips & Checklist to Do Well?
- WHAT TO SAY IN AN INTERVIEW: Tips on What To Say
- INTERVIEW QUESTIONS TO ASK CANDIDATES.
- 20 QUESTIONS TO ASK HIRING MANAGER IN 2023
References
