Which is better? RAID 0 vs. RAID 1? Well, before we go into that, we should probably define what RAID is.
RAID stands for Redundant Array of Independent Disks. It is a technology for storage units that offers a balanced flow and plenty of benefits, such as better fault tolerance, enhanced reliability, and high performance. It combines two or more disk storage arrays into logical units that behave like a single drive. This offers The grouping is implemented using software and hardware.
In simple terms, RAID allows multiple hard drives to couple with a single larger storage capacity disk.
Creating a larger storage space from numerous smaller drives also helps in different performance tasks. These include protection across drives to improve write and read speed and mirroring for data redundancy.
While most RAID levels can provide good protection against and recovery from hardware defects or defective sectors/read errors (hard errors), they do not offer any protection against data loss due to catastrophic failures (fire, water) or soft errors such as user error, software malfunction, or malware infection.
For valuable data, RAID is only one building block of a larger data loss prevention and recovery scheme – it cannot replace a backup plan.
How is RAID redundancy achieved?
The software to perform the RAID functionality and control the drives can either be located on a separate controller card (a hardware RAID controller) or it can simply be a driver. Some versions of Windows, such as Windows Server 2012 as well as Mac OS X, include software RAID functionality. Hardware RAID controllers cost more than pure software, but they also offer better performance, especially with RAID 5 and 6.
RAID-systems can be used with a number of interfaces, including SATA, SCSI, IDE, or FC (fiber channel.) There are systems that use SATA disks internally, but that have a FireWire or SCSI interface for the host system.
Sometimes disks in a storage system are defined as JBOD, which stands for Just a Bunch Of Disks. This means that those disks do not use a specific RAID level and act as stand-alone disks. This often occurs in drives that contain swap files or spooling data.
Whether for increased performance or reliability, upgrading a single disk to a RAID array of at least two disks will for sure make a big difference. There are a few common RAID configurations, and some unusual ones, each using different data storage distribution techniques.
However, most of the time, the first two levels, RAID 0 or RAID 1 will be enough for personal needs.
RAID 0 vs. RAID 1: What is RAID 0?
RAID 0 is a type of disk array that uses striping to combine multiple disks together. Also referred to as disk striping, it is a configuration that divides data across two or more disks into logical groups called stripes.
Disk striping is the process of writing individual sections of data on different disks. Data is distributed equally across all disks that are part of the array, with no regard to where it came from or where it needs to go. If you have 2 or more disks available for your computer, then you can create a stripe set by using the disks as one big drive letter.
For example, if you have two 80 GB hard drives on your computer, you would see them as ‘G:’ and ‘H:’. With this method, data can be written to both physical drives simultaneously which provides good speed for reading and writing files to the volume.
Because the information will be distributed over multiple drives, this decreases the potential for loss of data if a single disk goes down. This also speeds up access time since more than one drive spins at the same time to get one request. Because you have multiple disks to offer data to the operating system, read requests are notably faster, especially with a RAID controller with a decent amount of cache memory.
However, there is no fault tolerance with this setup and if either disk fails then all data will be lost. This is why this configuration is not recommended for mission-critical tasks. RAID 0 data recovery is considered one of the most challenging in the market and should only be attempted by professionals.
How Does RAID 0 Work?
A stripe includes data divided across SSDs or hard disks, and the striped unit defines the data slice on the individual drive. Since striping extends the data across physical drives, different disks can access contents, enabling reads and writes to be completed faster.
Disk striping, without parity for handling data, tends to have zero fault tolerance and redundancy. This means that when a drive fails, all the data on the drive will be lost. A system stripes data on different levels, such as byte-level, bite-level, block-level, or partition-level.
For example, a storage system has ten hard disks that strip a 64 KB block on the first, second, third, fourth, and fifth disks. It restarts from the first disk. Similarly, the system strips 1 MB of data on each of the 10 disks and returns to the first disks to repeat the procedure.
Thus, RAID 0 is one of the best technologies used for storage. Though it is non-critical, it requires high-speed writing and reading. Caching video editing and live streaming video are some use cases of RAID 0 due to its speed and performance.
RAID 0 vs. RAID 1: What is RAID 1?
RAID 1 is a type of disk array that uses mirroring to combine multiple disks together. Also referred to as disk mirroring, it is the RAID level that duplicates blocks of data on two disks. Everything that’s stored on the first disk is identical on the second disk.
In the case of RAID 1 technology, two or more identical hard disk drives are configured by grouping them simultaneously with configuration information known as mirroring. While they do not have to be exactly the same size, both disks must contain equal amounts of available space. Although both disks may contain the same information, they can be accessed independently for reading and writing purposes.
You can set up two or more disks as an exact duplicate. If one disk fails then the other will immediately take over and you’ll never know any difference until your failed disk has been replaced.
If either disk runs out of available space then it’s not possible to use RAID 1 anymore. Also, if one disk fails, there is no interruption to the user or the operating system. Windows, as an example, will have NO knowledge that one of the physical disks failed.
Hopefully, you have an alerting set up so you can take care of replacing that failed disk. And, as soon as you do, the RAID controller will automatically start copying the data back onto the replaced disk.
This increased data reliability makes RAID 1 data recovery more likely than RAID 0.
How Does RAID 1 Work?
The RAID array works if one drive is active and operational. As both the drives are operational, data can be read easily from them, which makes the operation fast. Since RAID 1 works well with SSDs for contemporary storage systems, many prefer “drive monitoring”.
However, writing operations are slower as each writing operation is done twice. During disaster recovery scenarios, only disk mirroring is helpful as it gives failover for the data that you need for mission-critical applications.
If the primary drive gets damaged or is not operational, traffic instantly switches to the mirrored or secondary backup drives. Then, the mirror copy can become operational because the application software and operating system are cloned to the drive along with the information by the applications.
Advantages and Limitations of RAID 0
Advantages
- Enhanced performance: RAID 0 offers higher speed and performance. Let’s understand this with an example. When the data is striped across three devices, it offers three times more bandwidth. If we assume every drive runs at 250 Input Output Operations per second, the setup will have 750 IOPS, making it super fast for you.
- No overhead: The entire capacity of each drive is used for storing as RAID 0 doesn’t use parity disks.
- Low cost: The configuration cost of RAID 0 is lesser and is supported by the RAID controllers.
- Easy to implement: You don’t need many skills to set up a RAID 0 level, making it quicker and easier to implement.
- Bandwidth: The bandwidth of RAID 0 is greater than single drives.
- Storage Capacity: It utilizes the complete storage capacity
Limitations
The main limitation of RAID 0 is that there is no parity, resulting in no fault tolerance. If your data is lost or corrupted for some reason, there is no backup or resiliency. This makes it impossible to retrieve any data.
The probability of failure with RAID 0 is higher than with single drives. Therefore, it is considered the ideal choice for critical systems.
Advantages and Limitations of RAID 1
Advantages
- Data redundancy: The major advantage of RAID 1 technology is data redundancy because data is duplicated across two or more disks.
- Fault tolerance: This type of storage is suitable for most mission-critical applications. When one drive fails, another drive takes over the primary duty. Since both drives include identical data, the users have no impact.
- High availability: Data is mirrored across two or more disks. So at the time of need or disaster recovery scenario, you can easily retrieve the data. Hence, the possibility of losing data is narrow.
- High performance: The data you use can be read from multiple devices simultaneously. Hence, it is relatively faster.
- High security: From a security point of view, RAID 1 provides data security by copying data at multiple places. Suppose one of your systems is hacked and you lose data; you can still access another.
Limitations
RAID 1 finds usage in many sectors due to its mirroring functionality. This level plays a crucial role in securing your data from personal to enterprise use. But it still has some limitations, which include:
- No real-time swapping: When the first disk fails, the secondary disk doesn’t take the role immediately or automatically. It needs to be restarted, which is a little bit of an inconvenience.
- Expensive: RAID 1 requires more space to implement. Thus, it is more costly compared to RAID 0.
- Reduced storage capacity: If you use two disks at a time and both contain the same data, your overall capacity gets halved.
- Performance: Read and write performance in RAID 1.
RAID 0 vs. RAID 1: Similarities
Similarities
- RAID 0 and RAID 1 are array levels.
- The primary use of both RAID levels is direct data management of the disk drives.
- Both technologies were conceived in 1987 and released in 1988.
- RAID 0 and RAID 1 are open formats.
- The technologies used in these levels are servers, virtualization, and hard drives.
- The minimum number of disks required is 2 for both arrays.
Differences
The largest differences between the two levels are their primary data storage functions. RAID 0 and RAID 1 handle their storage devices differently. RAID 0 puts all the drives in the RAID array into a single logical volume, whereas RAID 1 copies the primary drive to multiple drives in the array in real time.
This makes RAID 0 the fastest storage drive for reading and writing operations at a much lower cost. In contrast, RAID 1 becomes the safer option for enterprises for their data integrity and safety. Since both are full of advantages in their path, it will be challenging to decide which one to choose.
Below are the major differences between RAID 0 and RAID 1 side by side:
| RAID 0 | RAID 1 |
| RAID 0 means Redundant Array of Independent Disk level 0. | RAID 1 means Redundant Array of Independent Disk level 1. |
| In the RAID 0 array, disk striping is the primary operation. | In RAID 1, disk mirroring or duplication is the primary operation. |
| The cost is relatively lower. | It is costly as compared to RAID 0. |
| The read-and-write performance, along with speed, is high. | There is a written penalty. |
| The relative storage capacity is 100%. | The relative storage capacity is 50 %. |
| The read and write performance, along with speed, is high. | The read and write performance and speed are slower than RAID 0. |
| It emphasizes data accessing speed. | It emphasizes data availability. |
| There is no protection. | You will find mirror protection. |
| There is no redundancy, fault tolerance, and mirroring facility. | You will get redundancy, mirroring, and fault tolerance. |
| It’s used when the data reliability is less concerned, but speed is crucial. | It’s used when data loss is not acceptable. |
| Data is unrecoverable. | Data can be quickly recovered in a disaster recovery program. |
| Data is stored in one place. | Data can be stored in multiple places. |
| Two disks contain two different sets of data. | Two disks contain similar sets of data. |
RAID 0 vs. RAID 1: Which is better?
As stated above, there are pros and cons for both setups. If you’re using mission-critical data then RAID 1 is recommended.
However, most people choose to use RAID 0 because it is much faster. Besides, when one disk fails, the computer will continue to work without any downtime or errors. This makes RAID 0 a very popular choice in today’s modern world.
RAID 0 is made up of striping but does not have any duplication or parity disks as RAID 1 has. In other words, if two disks fail in a RAID 0 set-up, all information on those disks will be lost. This is because the only way to read data from it is if you have all of the pieces together at once.
On the other hand, RAID 1 uses half of the disks for storing mirror copies of the data, and the other half is used for parity calculation.
This allows one to see all of the data at both read and write times. In practice, it does not offer better performance than a single drive but increases your risk of complete loss due to multiple drive failures.
RAID 0 vs. RAID 1: When to Use Each
RAID 0
- If you need to create a logical volume on top of the volumes, such as creating volumes on RAID-protected LVM in Linux servers.
- If another form of data security is available, such as replica copy, network RAID, etc., in the event of losing data, it is a better option for personal use like PC gaming.
- It is your best option if you need 100% storage capacity and data loss is not a big problem as it’s less expensive.
RAID 1
- If data redundancy is your primary need
- If storage capacity and budget are not major issues but security is
- It is best suitable for mission-critical applications.
- If you want high Input Output Operations per Second (IOPS)
Recommended Articles
- Transaction Processing System: What It Means, Types & All to Know
- STACK INFRASTRUCTURE: Overview, Features, Alternatives & More
- SPEECH ANALYTICS: What Is It and How Does It Work?
- Dashboard Software: Top Best Dashboard Software in 2023
- IT ARCHITECT: What Is It & How to Become One
- Dell PowerScale: Features, Benefits & Alternatives
References
